Bigger brands are bigger mainly because more people buy them, and what people think of a brand is closely tied to using it. A system is how a growing organisation keeps both.
- 01
RobustBigger brands differ from smaller ones mainly in having many more buyers, and only slightly in how loyal those buyers are.
Ehrenberg, Goodhardt & Barwise (1990), Journal of Marketing; the “double jeopardy” pattern, found across many categories
- 02
RobustWhat people think of a brand is closely tied to using it. People who have used a brand hold more associations with it, so the product and service are likely to do much of the brand building.
Romaniuk, Bogomolova & Dall’Olmo Riley (2012), Journal of Advertising Research; 45 data sets
- 03
ModerateTrust moves more with what a brand does than with what it says. New-product activity had a larger association with trust than advertising intensity.
Rajavi, Kushwaha & Steenkamp (2019), Journal of Consumer Research; 15,073 people, 589 brands, 13 countries, packaged goods
- 04
WeakBrands that keep their assets, idea and tone stable for years produce advertising that tests better, and the gap widens over time.
System1 and the IPA, “Compound Creativity” (2024); 56 large UK brands, 4,164 TV ads. An industry study, not peer reviewed; System1 sells the test that supplies the measure, and success may be what allows consistency
- 05
ModerateAbrupt identity change is disliked most by the most committed customers. After a logo redesign, attitudes fell among strongly committed consumers and rose among weakly committed ones.
Walsh, Winterich & Mittal (2010), Journal of Product & Brand Management; 632 students, two brands
- 06
WeakReusable systems make consistent work quicker to produce. In two small tests, tasks were completed a third to a half faster with a design system.
Sparkbox (eight developers, one form); Figma (2019, sample undisclosed). Both run by firms that sell this work
Robust: meta-analysis, replication or very large samples. Moderate: one strong study, or several with limits. Weak: small studies, or run by an interested party.
/ Where the evidence stops
Nobody can put a reliable revenue figure on brand consistency; the percentages usually quoted trace to surveys of what marketers expected to happen. The consistency evidence is about advertising over years, it is industry-funded, and success may cause consistency as much as the reverse. We found no research on flexible identities, so “consistent, not rigid” is our design position, argued from how recognition and familiarity work, not a research finding.